This text was featured within the One Story to Learn At this time publication. Join it right here.
The final time we noticed him, we noticed all of him.
Our topic is Anthony Weiner, whose surname was a burden lengthy earlier than it grew to become a curse—so fused along with his shame which you can’t say it with out triggering an avalanche of cringe. Weiner, who was caught texting photos of his penis, first denied it, then admitted it, then resigned from Congress, then ran for mayor of New York Metropolis, at which level he sexted once more underneath the alias Carlos Hazard, was caught once more, misplaced the election, sexted a photograph along with his younger son within the background, sexted a minor, and forfeited a laptop computer with emails from his estranged spouse that brought on the FBI to reopen its Hillary Clinton electronic mail investigation, greasing the way in which for Donald Trump’s 2016 victory and hastening the doable finish of the republic and democracy as we all know it.
However for Weiner, even that wasn’t sufficient.
Virtually 14 years after he by accident posted the primary lewd photograph to his Twitter account, and 6 years after he walked out of a minimum-security jail, having served 18 months for transferring obscene materials to a minor, Weiner is operating for metropolis council in New York. Is his candidacy a check of America’s capability to forgive? A provocation for Democrats to cease clutching their pearls whereas Trump gropes his solution to authoritarianism?
One consequence of residing in an age when nothing appears to matter is an inclination, a minimum of in some folks, to overcorrect and demand that all the pieces issues. The return of Anthony Weiner raises Huge Societal Questions, and if that’s your factor, have at it.
My very own pursuits are extra slender. For starters, I stay within the downtown-Manhattan district Weiner is hoping to characterize. (As an impartial, I’m not eligible to vote within the major.) Then there’s this: Weiner is the cherry atop some of the absurd major seasons in New York Metropolis historical past. On June 24, Democrats will make a mayoral selection from a big discipline of candidates that features a vengeful former governor who resigned after accusations of sexual harassment that he has denied (Andrew Cuomo). There’s additionally a socialist who desires to make use of subway stations to accommodate much more homeless folks than they at present do. The massively unpopular now-you’re-indicted, now-you’re-not incumbent (Eric Adams) is operating as an impartial. Weiner’s high rival within the city-council race is a beforehand nameless assemblyman who went viral when Saturday Evening Dwell spoofed his identify—Harvey Epstein—which is in some way much more unlucky than Weiner’s. We have to hurry up and vote earlier than Rudy Giuliani will get any concepts.
Once I first contacted Weiner, I figured he is perhaps subdued by having to play the penitent. There’s not a lot proof of his marketing campaign within the neighborhood, and his one-word electronic mail response to my interview request felt like a sigh: “Okay.”
I shouldn’t have been involved. Two weeks later, we met for breakfast. He’s nonetheless slim as a minnow, loud as a gong. “I’m a fucking Rorschach!” Weiner instructed me exuberantly.
“My factor is so sui generis,” he continued. “Everybody that I discuss to concerning the race, they essentially know completely what method I ought to take. Some individuals are like, ‘You need to say, “Fuck it. Donald Trump acquired elected as a 34-time felon.” Or lean into it, you already know. Make a joke about it.’ And about an equal variety of folks say, ‘You bought to spend the primary 4 or 5 items of mail apologizing, explaining that you just served your no matter it’s, you’ve discovered your lesson.’”
Spending time with Weiner is like residing inside an episode of The Bear. The profanity and fervor are relentless—and seemingly inextricable from the expertise. Even with greater than a decade of political rust on him, it solely took a couple of minutes to be reminded that tact is usually simply the primary casualty of his convictions.
Take, as an example, his views on the Democratic Occasion, which he believes has grow to be a form of emotional-support pet for each progressive curiosity. “Voters don’t anticipate you to have each reply and to agree with them on all the pieces,” Weiner mentioned, his face scrunched in exaggerated bewilderment. “Typically they really form of prefer it if you say, ‘Fuck me? Fuck you.’ That is extra of an acknowledgment that you just’re truly listening to them than simply saying ‘Sure, I agree.’”
If confrontation is the deepest type of love, Weiner is the Buddha. That’s the beneficiant take. The much less beneficiant one is that he’s obsessive—he’s by no means met a boundary he respects or a consequence he fears. That his certainty and enthusiasm are tied up with a have to dominate. That he’s not merely tumescent; he wants you to see it.
Self-knowledge will be overrated, however Weiner, deep into his fourth decade in public life, has by no means been notably good at disguising or explaining any of this. “I’m unsure the place the snake is consuming its tail—did I’ve a necessity that was being fed by my profession? Did I am going into that profession as a result of I used to be coping with these inside demons and no matter?” He’s the one topic the place his conviction has constantly failed him. A Rorschach check even to himself.
Weiner’s newest comeback started at a countertop firm within the Brooklyn Navy Yard. When Weiner left jail in 2020, a pal who owned the place and believed in using the previously incarcerated put in Weiner as its CEO. After the corporate grew to become an employee-owned co-op, Weiner moved on to consulting earlier than touchdown a daily gig because the left-wing foil on WABC, a conservative talk-radio station that doubles as a rescue shelter for New York’s unloved political animals.
Given the size of the harm he’d brought on, this was greater than he had a proper to hope for. Radio scratched an itch, and the hours allowed him to “make life as straightforward as doable for Huma”—Abedin, his ex-wife, famously an adviser to Hillary Clinton—and to be round for his or her then-9-year-old son, Jordan. Weiner frames this era as “a call to stay a smaller life,” earlier than including, “Now, I’m open to the concept that I don’t need the final chapter to be ‘He served time in jail, got here again, and went on terrestrial radio.’ I imply, I’m open to the concept that I didn’t like that final chapter.”
In 2024, Jordan reached the start of what parenting consultants name the launching stage, and what Weiner jokingly calls a baby’s “simply doesn’t give a shit about having me round anymore” part. On the similar time, a term-limited seat in our shared city-council district opened. Weiner assessed the sphere, determined that “there’s not a Muhammad Ali on this fucking race,” and known as Huma, with whom he shares custody.
“My first response was wanting reassurance that there was minimal affect on Jordan,” Abedin instructed me. “And I additionally know that was the rationale why I used to be the primary individual he requested. I’ve by no means doubted that Anthony was and is a really gifted and charismatic politician, and was efficient as a congressman. These are simply details. Only a few people who find themselves aware of his work disagree or dispute that, placing apart any human shortcomings. I’ve moved on with my life. And I’m glad he’s moved on along with his, so I mentioned, ‘I hope you will discover pleasure and function in doing this.’ That’s mainly it. It was a brief dialog.”
Then Weiner made one other name. “I’ve the sponsor, and he says, ‘You need to consistently be interested by what your motives are.’ Like, that was his first query.”
Anthony Weiner has a sponsor as a result of Anthony Weiner is a intercourse addict. He doesn’t fairly squirm whereas speaking about it, however it’s the uncommon topic that causes him to decelerate, to think about his phrases somewhat than spit them out like spent shell casings. “Let me simply begin by saying I’m not making an attempt to influence you or anybody else who desires to argue about whether or not intercourse dependancy’s a factor or not.” Pause. “However the easiest method to take a look at it.” Pause. “In case you outline dependancy within the medical approach of doing one thing that, if you attempt to cease and may’t, if you want extra of that factor regardless of having increasingly more penalties for not with the ability to cease.”
For the document, the DSM-5 (the Diagnostic and Statistical Guide of Psychological Issues, revealed by the American Psychiatric Affiliation) doesn’t embrace intercourse dependancy as a proper prognosis. The World Well being Group’s Worldwide Classification of Ailments does, however calls it compulsive sexual conduct dysfunction. A minimum of initially, Weiner was extra of a DSM-5 man. “I used to be skeptical,” he mentioned. “I used to be an individual who had this exaggerated perception in my very own skill and labored actually arduous. So regardless that I misplaced my brother to dependancy”—his older brother, Seth, struggled with medication and alcohol and was inebriated when hit by a automotive as he crossed a Virginia freeway on foot in 2000—“I by no means fairly internalized it as a factor, proper?”
Like lots of people, all-time low is what pressured him to rethink. In 2016, as he misplaced his spouse, youngster, freedom, and probably the election of the primary feminine president, Weiner couldn’t perceive the way it had all occurred. “I knew that I couldn’t cease. I knew that I used to be doing it an unlimited quantity, regardless of rising penalties. When folks say ‘What have been you pondering?,’ I couldn’t reply.”
“I’m not a sufferer of some bigger conspiracy,” he mentioned. “It’s only a factor that I did that I’ve accepted accountability for.” He credit the rituals of restoration—the naming of his situation; 12 steps; group conferences, which he says he nonetheless attends—for offering a ladder up: “It introduced me reduction. However I wish to watch out that I’m not, like, an skilled or exemplar or something.”
It’s not possible to know if Weiner has actually grow to be extra decipherable to himself. He says all of the issues a honest individual would say about dependancy—that are additionally the issues a intelligent insincere individual would say. We stay in an period when each scoundrel has a pathology. It’s arduous to think about an individual much less suited to the Serenity Prayer.
He a minimum of appears to have arrived at an understanding that the forces inside him can’t be dissociated. I requested if politics and sexting have been intertwined compulsions, if chasing votes would result in the world waking as much as one other shot of his junk on social media. “I fear about it rather a lot,” he replied. Weiner mentioned he acquired sober in 2016. However there’s nonetheless classic materials on the market from the Carlos Hazard period. “A part of the danger of all that is that individuals are like, ‘Sorry, I didn’t get an opportunity to money in then, however I’ve acquired this textual content from no matter.’”
As for motive, Weiner listened to his sponsor and requested himself if he was chasing fame (“no”), redemption (“slightly”), or motion (“I did have the sense I ain’t doing sufficient”). He checked out his life. Jordan and Abedin are thriving and won’t be liable to monetary break ought to he implode. (Weiner and Abedin separated in 2016 and formally divorced in early 2025; Abedin is now engaged to George Soros’s son Alex.) “I imply, look, to some extent, that is what I’m actually good at. It’s as fundamental as that,” Weiner mentioned. “From there, it turns into, Properly, if I do have this skill, and that skill interprets into a greater metropolis and a greater neighborhood for my son, why not do it? After which the reply is often some model of: Persons are gonna say imply issues to you. I don’t need folks to be imply to me, however that didn’t look like all that good a purpose. So right here we’re.”
To seem on New York Metropolis’s major poll, candidates for metropolis council want 450 folks to signal a petition supporting their candidacy. The Weiner marketing campaign has no headquarters and one full-time staffer, so the candidate grabbed a clipboard. “Once I first acquired on the market, I had fight-or-flight at each door,” Weiner instructed me. “It’s not like I’ve acquired a strategic view of the way to take care of the scandal. I’m making an attempt to take care of these items with honesty. Even when I needed to do a ballot and say, ‘All proper, what do you suppose?,’ I’d need to learn, like, two pages of preamble, proper?”
Just a few folks opened their doorways, noticed Anthony Weiner, and began yelling—and by now it shouldn’t shock you that he yelled again. Some gently teased him or confirmed him grace. Most barely acknowledged him. Some mistook him for Andrew Cuomo, or Eliot Spitzer (“Flawed Jew,” Weiner instructed me), or by no means knew him within the first place. This tracks with my very own expertise of being in public with Weiner. Just a few glances, however time has handed. Recognition fades. So many pariahs underneath the bridge. “I get a number of ‘Boy, you have to be a glutton for punishment,’’’ he mentioned. “Or somebody will say ‘I imagine in second probabilities,’ or ‘I voted for you earlier than; I’ll vote for you once more,’ that form of factor. However I at all times embrace in my calculus that folks will say good issues and usually maintain nasty issues to themselves, particularly if you’re on the market face-to-face.”
Weirdly, the most important impediment to Weiner’s comeback could also be not his previous, however his politics. He’s lived in District 2 since 2011, however it’s removed from the principally white, middle-class elements of Queens and Brooklyn he represented as a congressman. Each District 2 council member for the reason that early Nineteen Nineties has been Hispanic. Simply 8 p.c of the district’s 175,000 residents are registered Republicans. Recent Defund the Police graffiti seems recurrently. Our rats share their pronouns.
Weiner’s a centrist Democrat—he thinks the neighborhood wants extra cops and fewer pot retailers. “If this election is about essentially the most anti-Trump, crazy-making individual on the left, you’re not going to choose a Cuomo or a Weiner,” he mentioned. “Now, I might be fully unsuitable, however there appears to be a disconnect with the model that New York Democrats are promoting and what folks wish to purchase proper now.” I requested what proof he needed to help this. “I’m in New York with a head on my shoulders seeing what’s happening on 14th Road.”
The minimalist composer Philip Glass is a longtime District 2 resident. I point out this as a result of the Weiner marketing campaign is mainly simply two loud hunches, performed repeatedly, in a approach which will or could not cohere right into a melody.
The primary hunch is focusing the marketing campaign relentlessly on quality-of-life points, with average to conservative positions on subway-fare evasion (cease it), sidewalk scaffolding (cease it), and the current proliferation of missile-like E-bikes in bike lanes (cease it). Technocratic intolerance for dysfunction was final a factor in New York Metropolis throughout the Bloomberg administration, however it’s hardly novel.
That is the place the second hunch is available in. Given Democrats’ typically foul temper, it’s not sufficient to be average. To succeed in the citizens, moderates should even be offended. “You understand, often we affiliate firebrands with an excessive form of factor,” Weiner mentioned. “Properly, what if the hearth is simply, like, Ya gotta accumulate the fucking rubbish, man?”
I watched some sport tape of Weiner at candidate boards and interest-group Zooms from the previous few months. The reality is that these occasions will be each a bore and a circus. Typically Weiner was the clown—“I’ll take questions on something. And you already know what I imply by this.”
However extra usually, I smiled, as you do watching anybody be glorious at one thing.
When a Service Workers Worldwide Union (SEIU) group that represents medical residents and interns instructed him that its high precedence is extra housing near hospitals, Weiner shot again, “Am I going to try this for the firefighters additionally? Am I going to try this for the fellows who work within the sanitation division? You inform me the way you anticipate this to work.” He didn’t sound just like the unreasonable one. From the Village Impartial Democrats, he took a easy query a few native homeless man and, with compassion, lit into the progressive orthodoxy on homelessness—which prioritizes an unhoused individual’s proper to remain on the road over getting troubled folks needed care and preserving public areas.
Most politicians know the way to stay on the floor in these moments. However Weiner makes use of battle to make small issues really feel extra pressing, to make native democracy into one thing worthy of ardour. He’s not a stupendous speaker, however he challenges Democrats to listen to the jagged melody blaring by means of his septum: Will we wish to be well mannered, or can we wish to resolve this? If I’m prepared to battle with you, think about how arduous I’ll battle for you.
Weiner has few methods to know if any of that is working. He and his rivals are on the verge of reaching the council fundraising cap, $207,000, and none of them can afford a correct ballot, so he screens the indicators that he can. Endorsements are spotty, although, notably, the SEIU group went with Harvey Epstein. The New York Occasions seems to seek out him too prurient to cowl, whereas the New York Submit sticks to dick jokes and contempt.
When he entered the race, a rival candidate proposed the Withholding Eligibility in NYC Elections for Restricted People Act, or WEINER Act, to ban registered intercourse offenders from searching for workplace. On this, Weiner noticed a hopeful glimmer of concern. However at the latest candidate discussion board, his opponents appeared to have settled on a sequence of shared facial expressions that convey endurance and pity. They patronized whilst he schooled them on the basics, like standing if you reply a voter’s query and underlining your coverage variations from the remainder of the sphere.
Other than voters, Weiner appears most determined to listen to from the old-guard New York Democrats who as soon as embraced him as the long run. He hasn’t spoken with Cuomo or Chuck Schumer—his political mentor, the person whose congressional seat he inherited—in years. He has ideas about how they need to discuss to voters. (When Schumer blinked in his March staredown with Trump and funded the federal government with a unbroken decision, Weiner instructed me, “What number of instances did Chuck say ‘CR, CR, CR’? Simply say ‘They wish to shut down the federal government as a result of in the event that they do, they’re by no means gonna reopen it.’ English!”) He says he desires to be helpful, however within the meantime he’s glad to make use of them as a foil. “I do lean into the concept that there’s not a lot they will do to me, proper? I’m not operating with their institutional help. I’m not asking for it in an actual approach. And in addition, I’m not going to wilt very simply. When you have Mayor Cuomo, I’m going to be the tallest pygmy within the metropolis council.”
I requested Weiner what occurs if he loses, and he reached for an “I’m not that man anymore” story. Again within the Nineteen Nineties, when he was first operating for Congress, Brooklyn had one 24-hour grocery store. “So at 2 o’clock within the morning, I’m like, ‘I’ve nowhere else to be. I’ll be on the grocery store, discuss to some voters.’ There’s nobody there!” He laughed.
So what does he do at 2 a.m. now?
“I’m not operating round each second of the day like I’ve to be maximizing my voter contact. However campaigning now, right here in Manhattan, that’s very totally different than it was after I did this in Brooklyn in 1991. And hear, if I wish to attain folks at 2 a.m., there are folks I can attain.”
I hoped he’d say “sleep.”
This text initially misidentified New York Metropolis Mayor Eric Adams as a candidate within the Democratic major for mayor. He’s operating as an impartial.
